Methodology, version 1.0

How we rank.

One rubric, applied the same way to all 260 providers, with the weights and the math published.

Last updated August 1, 2026

Every provider on this site is scored out of 100 on the same seven dimensions, with the weights published below. Nothing about that score is negotiable, and nothing about it is for sale.

Provider scores are temporarily hidden while spas review, claim and correct their listings. The rubric and the weights on this page are unchanged. Each provider page lists what its public evidence is missing, and has a claim or correct link.

Most "best med spa" lists are advertising with a headline on top. Somebody paid, or somebody's affiliate link is buried in the button. I wanted the version that doesn't exist yet: one rubric, applied the same way to every provider in Boulder County, with the math shown.

The seven dimensions

DimensionWeightWhat it measures
Verified client reviews20%Rating, volume and recency together, plus how specific recent reviews are. A 5.0 from 40 reviews does not outrank a 4.9 earned across 800, and reviews that name an actual procedure or an actual clinician count for more than "great staff".
Provider credentials and medical oversight20%Whether real licensed clinicians are named, how many, and what licenses they hold. In Colorado a physician or nurse practitioner acts on their own authority while an unlicensed injector acts as a physician's delegatee, so a named license tells you more than a named medical director.
Price transparency20%Graded, not yes-or-no. Full marks for a real per-unit, per-syringe or per-session price. Partial for a vague "starting at". Nothing for nothing.
Consultation quality15%Whether the consult is honest and unhurried, and whether they'll tell you when a treatment is wrong for you. Assessed in person, and not in the score yet.
Facility and safety10%Cleanliness, equipment, and how the space is run. Assessed in person, and not in the score yet.
Range of services10%How much they actually do, taken from their own published service pages.
Booking experience5%How hard it is to actually get an appointment.

What's scored now, and what waits for a visit

Five of the seven dimensions come from public evidence: credentials, reviews, services, pricing, and booking. Those are live for all 260 providers today, and the scores are calculated only from those five, renormalized so the math still lands on 100. The five public dimensions add up to 75 points, and the published score is that total divided by 75, multiplied by 100, and rounded, so it still reads as a score out of 100.

Consultation quality and facility safety can't be judged from a website. I'd rather show you a partial score honestly than a complete-looking one I made up, so right now every score is built from the five dimensions I can measure from public evidence, stretched to a 0-100 scale.

Here's the wrinkle, and I'd rather explain it than quietly work around it. If I start folding visit scores into the number as I go, the first providers I visit get measured against all seven dimensions while everyone else is measured against five. A place could score well on my visit and still drop in the rankings, purely for having been visited. That's backwards, and it would also give me a quiet lever over the rankings, which is the whole thing this site exists not to have.

So visits currently do two things: the profile gets a dated "visited in person" mark, and it gets my written take. The score stays put. Once enough providers have been visited for the comparison to be fair, the two in-person dimensions go into the number for everyone at once, and I'll say plainly on this page when that happens.

A worked example: The Luxe Room, Boulder

Here is what the rubric looks at for one provider, so you can see the kind of evidence behind it. The Luxe Room in Boulder is the example. Everything below comes from their own website (credentials, prices, services, booking) and their Google reviews as stored on this site: 5.0 stars across 346 reviews. The Google rating and review count are as recorded in our dataset on July 24, 2026. Credentials, prices, services and booking are as recorded in our dataset on July 29, 2026. I have not visited The Luxe Room in person, so nothing here comes from a visit. While provider scores are hidden, the points and the arithmetic for this example are hidden too.

DimensionWeightWhat the evidence showed
Provider credentials and medical oversight20%One licensed clinician is named on their site: Danielle Mathers, RN (14 pages read). No physician, PA or nurse practitioner is named, and the site doesn't mention a medical director or board certification.
Verified client reviews20%A 5.0 rating across 346 reviews. The rating is weighed together with the number of reviews it was earned across. There isn't enough recent review text on file for this provider, so specificity doesn't enter this one.
Price transparency20%Real prices are published on their website.
Range of services10%Four published service groups (injectables, laser, medical skincare, medical weight loss). Five or more earns full marks.
Booking experience5%No online booking was found.

If you want to check the code: credentials are scored in scripts/build_directory.py, function cred() (lines 237 to 256), with service range on line 272 and the point weights on lines 278 to 286. The review points and the published total are written by scripts/enrich_providers.py, function main() (lines 217 to 236).

Why price transparency is weighted so heavily

Because it's the industry's worst habit, and because it's the one thing on this list a business can fix this afternoon.

Of the providers on this site, fewer than a third publish a real per-unit or per-session price. Most ask you to book a consultation to find out what something costs, which is a sales appointment wearing a medical coat. At 20 percent, and with only five of the seven dimensions currently scored, publishing prices moves a provider a long way up this list. That is deliberate. A clinic that won't tell you the price before you're in the chair does not belong at the top of an honest ranking, however good its credentials are.

It's graded rather than a tick box. A published per-syringe or per-unit price earns full marks. A "packages starting at $X" earns partial credit, because it's better than silence but it still isn't a number you can compare.

How the review score works

Star averages on their own are close to useless in this industry. Nearly everyone sits between 4.7 and 5.0, and a brand new clinic with eleven glowing reviews will show a perfect score.

So the review dimension weighs the rating, the volume it was earned across, and how specific recent reviews actually are. A rating built from hundreds of reviews counts for more than the same rating from a handful.

The specificity part is worth explaining, because it's unusual. I count the share of a provider's past-year reviews that name a real procedure or a real clinician, at any star rating. Not just the glowing ones. A detailed one-star review is some of the best evidence on the internet, and the rating is already scored separately, so filtering specificity down to five-star reviews would just count positivity twice and reward clinics that coach reviewers on what to write.

How credentials are scored, and a correction

This dimension looks for licenses attached to actual named people on a provider's own site: how many clinicians are named, whether a physician is among them, whether a PA or nurse practitioner is, and whether the practice states board certification or a medical director.

It didn't always. Until 27 July 2026 this dimension was mostly a business-category constant plus a bonus that, because of a bug in how credentials were detected, every single provider received. It barely distinguished anyone. It does now, and some scores moved a long way as a result. I'd rather say that plainly than quietly change the numbers.

Where the data comes from

What would change a score

Scores aren't frozen. They move when a provider publishes pricing, adds or loses a credentialed provider, changes their service menu, or accumulates a meaningfully different body of reviews. If you own one of these businesses and something here is out of date or wrong, tell me and I'll check it.

What this is not

It's not medical advice, and it isn't a safety certification. A high score means a provider looks strong on the things I can measure. It doesn't mean a given treatment is right for you, and it isn't a substitute for a real consultation with a licensed clinician who has examined you.

The scoring is versioned. This is version 1.0, published July 2026. If the method changes, the change gets noted here rather than quietly applied.

See all providers